“Can you hear me now?”
Southold residents overwhelmingly want their cell service fixed and are willing to accept more infrastructure to do it — especially if towers are visually concealed and placed on public property, according to the results of a Southold Town survey.
“A lot of people really voiced an opinion that they rely on their cell phones for work and health care and daily connectivity, and that they have a real concern for not having access to calling 911 in the event of an emergency,” said Susan Rabold, a consultant for Cityscape Consulting, which conducted the 30-question survey. “And that theme … surfaced throughout the poll.”
The poll, which ran from July 18 to Aug. 14, generated 773 online responses and focused strictly on wireless telephone connectivity, not home broadband. The goal was to capture people’s experience with their current phones and “what they would support for future sites,” Rabold told the Southold Town Board at a work session on Tuesday.
Other top line data from the survey found that inside the home, almost half of all respondents reported “one bar” — which the survey categorized as poor — with another large group (22%) calling service only “acceptable.” Sixty-one percent of respondents said they use Verizon as their carrier.
On the road, about 50% called coverage poor and 35.5% said it is inconsistent. More than 93% of respondents “entirely agree” that service quality is important, and about 81% said they would rely more on their mobile devices if the network improved. Many residents said they depend on Wi-Fi indoors to compensate and repeatedly cited safety worries about being unable to call 911.
When residents were asked where coverage is worst, Rabold said the Southold hamlet center “was a real concern,” with 246 mentions, followed by persistent complaints along the Main Road corridor. The survey recorded 636 location comments overall, including many street-level “onesies and twosies” — where a respondent indicated a specific location on their street where service was poor.
Concealed sites
“The community was very vocal that they are really concerned about the coverage, and there were a lot of comments that indicated that they really just want the coverage and that they kind of don’t really care what it looks like,” Rabold said. “But when they came into their voting, their voting was predominantly for concealed sites.
For non-concealed towers (lattice, monopole, guyed), 45% said they could support all; 14% said none. For concealed/visually mitigated towers, 45% preferred the “monopine” (a faux tree) and another 45% said all concealed options were acceptable. When forced to choose among macro designs later in the survey, 75.6% preferred visually mitigated facilities.
Residents also endorsed a hybrid build-out, according to Rabold. “The majority indicat[ed] that a hybrid mix of both macro and small cells is what they would prefer to see.” Macro refers to the towers, while small cells can be attached to existing infrastructure like telephone poles where necessary.
Asked about small cells specifically, 52.7% supported all configurations, and about 51–52% favored poles designed for co-location to host multiple carriers.
Earlier this summer, former Southold Town Supervisor Scott Russell told the North Fork Sun that years ago the town passed a restrictive cell tower law.
“We passed a code that was so strict it invariably ended up discouraging the very things we now need, which are cell towers,” said Russell, who stepped down as supervisor in 2023 after serving for 18 years. “Unfortunately, we were the victims of our own success.”
The law limited tower height, restricted their location to areas like industrial zones and subjected proposals to a rigorous review process.
“Obviously, you don’t want them going in willy-nilly,” he said. “At the same time … every time someone proposed a cell tower, the community went nuts.”

Where to build new infrastructure
On Tuesday, Rabold walked through projection maps that assume every existing site is maximized and able to host all four national carriers. She emphasized those maps show more coverage than exists today because not every provider is installed on every structure; the modeling is meant to reveal gaps that remain even after maximization.
Fishers Island emerged as a priority gap. A church steeple there already hosts limited equipment, but “not all four [carriers] can fit on that one steeple,” Rabold said. Adding a concealed macro cell near the local golf course (east) and another near the fire station (west) could give “equal opportunity for all four providers.”
One big issue is height. Modeling showed that one existing lattice site known as SO9 covers far more area at 199 feet than 145 foot towers.
“You could be getting more [coverage] if [towers] were taller,” Rabold said, while acknowledging the town still needs to test how far the community will go on height.
Rabold said that placement preferences were clear, with strong support for new infrastructure going on town-owned property, other public property and non-residential private parcels. Conversely, there was little support for placement on agricultural-zoned land, which Rabold said “takes those out of the equation” on the design side. Asked directly whether to use town land, 56% said yes for all reasons listed — from siting control and design standards to maintenance oversight and the generation of lease revenue.
The survey also tested whether residents would accept concealed towers other than “unipoles,” which hide antennas inside the pole but can restrict radio performance. “We learned that 82% could support other concealed strategies besides the unipole,” Rabold said.
Roughly 30 respondents suggested specific private-property locations as possible host sites, and about 70% asked to stay informed as the project advances.
Southold’s current code “emphasizes aesthetics and scenic preservation,” Rabold said. Based on the survey — and updated federal rules — she recommended that a first draft of code amendments:
- Add an explicit policy priority for coverage and public safety.
- Raise height caps because there is community support for taller concealed and non-concealed towers.
- Move beyond a unipole-only preference and allow a variety of concealment types “worked out on a site-by-site basis.”
- Create pathways for administrative approvals with strict design standards for clearly supported sites (for example, a 120-foot concealed tower at the Fishers Island fire station), while reserving special exceptions for proposals that exceed those standards (such as taller or non-concealed towers).
- Codify a detailed order-of-preference that prioritizes co-location and public sites and forces applicants to demonstrate why higher-ranked options won’t work before proposing a new standalone tower.
Communications
Later in the work session, Southold Town officials discussed a plan to overhaul a different kind of communication. Councilman Brian Mealy and Town Clerk Denis Noncarrow want to improve how the town communicates with residents — from emergency alerts and social media to its decade-old website. Both officials said the town website needs an update that addresses generational differences in technology use.

Mealy told colleagues that he is often asked why the town’s website is “so confusing, or ‘how can we get information that’s important when there is an emergency?'”
Mealy said that he and Noncarrow want to form a new communications committee to “make a concerted effort to finally deal with it. We’ve been talking about it for years. Many iterations of the board have dealt with it.”
Noncarrow described how other municipalities have improved communications by zeroing in on how residents prefer to receive information, and pointed to a student apprentice who helped draft Southold’s first survey.
“He was in high school, and his way of getting information was totally different from what we were thinking … information comes through so many different ways,” Noncarrow said.


