A top Suffolk County law enforcement official on Tuesday defended the use of automated license plate readers on the North Fork, detailing their role in solving hit-and-run crashes, locating missing persons and apprehending dangerous fugitives, while acknowledging that the rapidly expanding technology warrants greater oversight and more uniform regulations.

In a hour-long presentation and discussion during the Southold Town Board’s morning work session on Tuesday, Suffolk County Chief Deputy Sheriff Christopher Brockmeyer sought to address growing public concerns about the use of Flock Safety cameras. He outlined the department’s internal safeguards while recognizing some of the challenges inherent in entrusting sensitive law enforcement data to private technology companies and sharing it with police agencies across the country.

Brockmeyer also said that the sheriff’s office has data-sharing relationships with slightly more than 400 law enforcement agencies and that those relationships are established through settings within the Flock system rather than formal, written agreements.

“Whenever government agencies use tools that collect information, the public has a right to understand how those tools work, why they are used and what safeguards exist to protect individual privacy and civil liberty,” he told the board.

Brockmeyer, who marks 28 years with the sheriff’s office this week, was joined by Investigator Sgt. Richard Tedesco, who heads the department’s police technology operations, and Owen Durney, its director of intergovernmental relations.

Tuesday’s discussion follows mounting local and national scrutiny of the proliferation of automated license plate readers, commonly known as ALPRs. In Southold, three Flock cameras are operated by the town police department and another eight by the sheriff’s office.

While the sheriff’s office has been using license plate readers since the early 2000s, Brockmeyer said a more extensive deployment of fixed-location cameras began in 2024, following the receipt of a state grant. Working with East End police departments, the sheriff’s office identified major transportation corridors and bypass routes, installing most of its cameras along county and state roads and at key county facilities.

The cameras capture still images of passing vehicles and their license plates, recording the date, time and location of each sighting. Investigators can search the database retrospectively or receive real-time alerts for vehicles associated with crimes, stolen vehicles, fugitives and missing persons.

Brockmeyer stressed that an alert alone is not sufficient grounds for an arrest and that officers must independently investigate.

He cited a number of applications of the technology with particular relevance to the North Fork, including investigations of serious and fatal hit-and-run crashes and financial scams targeting elderly residents.

In the latter cases, he said, victims are often unable to recall a license plate number but can provide detectives with a vehicle’s make, model or color — enough information to potentially generate investigative leads.

“The technology’s ability to quickly identify and track vehicle movements across jurisdictions has proven invaluable in locating vulnerable individuals and coordinating timely response,” he said.

In one instance, a camera at Francis S. Gabreski Airport in Westhampton Beach generated an alert for a vehicle associated with a person from several states away who was believed to be suicidal. Deputies located the individual, ensured their safety and notified their family and authorities in their home jurisdiction, he said.

In another recent case, involving a shooting in Huntington, investigators used vehicle descriptions and license plate reader technology to trace a suspect vehicle across the Throgs Neck Bridge, through Pennsylvania and eventually to Birmingham, Alabama, where authorities were able to deploy fugitive task force personnel. The suspects were attempting to flee toward the border, Brockmeyer said.

The operation unfolded within 18 hours.

Brockmeyer also argued that the technology can reduce unnecessary interactions between police and the public. Where officers might previously have stopped several blue SUVs following a report of a crime, for instance, investigators can now narrow their search using distinguishing characteristics, such as front-end damage or a roof rack.

He sought to put the sensitivity of license plate data into a broader law enforcement context, noting that police agencies have long been entrusted with criminal histories, residential addresses, DNA evidence and sensitive photographs and videos.

“These types of records contain significantly more personal information than a still image of a vehicle and its license plate captured on an ALPR system,” he said.

The sheriff’s office retains license plate reader data for 30 days, after which it is automatically deleted from the system, Brockmeyer said. Audit logs documenting who accessed the system, when they accessed it and their justification for conducting a search are retained beyond that period.

The department has also brought in a professional auditor with experience in the county comptroller’s office to independently review searches, including those conducted by participating East End police departments.

“Misuse or abuse of the ALPR system will not be tolerated,” Brockmeyer said, adding that violations could result in administrative, disciplinary or criminal proceedings.

Several Town Board members, however, expressed concerns that extended beyond the conduct of local police officers.

Councilwoman Alexa Suess pressed the sheriff’s officials on the security of data stored by Flock, including questions about encryption and the extent to which local law enforcement agencies can independently ensure that information is protected.

Councilwoman Alexa Suess, who wore a mask because she was sick and didn’t want to infect anyone, questioned county officials about Flock cameras. Credit: Chris Francescani

Brockmeyer said that he was not personally familiar with the mechanics of Flock’s encryption system, but said the county requires its vendors to meet established security standards and would reevaluate its relationship with a company found to be violating those standards.

In a subsequent exchange with Councilwoman Kate Stevens, Brockmeyer acknowledged the difficulty of independently monitoring private companies operating hundreds or thousands of miles away.

“Who’s checking the checkers, right?” he said.

He acknowledged that doing business with such companies involves a degree of trust and said government agencies need to ensure they have qualified personnel in place to hold their vendors accountable.

County Legislator Greg Doroski, who attended Tuesday’s work session, raised similar concerns about the scope of the department’s data-sharing network, suggesting that public confidence in local police does not necessarily extend to law enforcement agencies elsewhere in the country.

Brockmeyer said the sheriff’s office generally requires reciprocal access from agencies with which it shares data.

Asked about those arrangements, however, he acknowledged that they do not involve written memorandums of understanding or formal interagency agreements.

Tedesco likened the process to establishing connections on social media platforms such as Facebook or LinkedIn, where one party agrees to share information and the other reciprocates.

Brockmeyer said he anticipates that the national debate over license plate readers will eventually produce more standardized regulations governing their use, auditing and information-sharing practices — an initiative he said he would personally support.

He also said he welcomed continued discussions with elected officials and community members, admitting that the national controversy has already prompted the sheriff’s office to revisit and update its own policies.

“The moment we lose the trust of the community, then what is it all for?” he said.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *