Missing mail, territorial disputes and ferry deadlines kept Southold police busy this week. A standoff over a package at the Fishers Island Post Office required police intervention, while a motorist clocked at more than 80 mph in Mattituck told an officer he was late for a ferry. Elsewhere, a former gun club member was accused of hunting on his old stomping grounds, a Greenport West neighbor was suspected of taking a stick to a surveillance camera and a Cutchogue woman going through a divorce suspected her estranged husband of stockpiling her mail in a locked shed. Southold police responded to 47 incidents last week, and here are some of the highlights:
Nov. 10 – Around 1 p.m., police were called to a scene on Sound Ave. in Mattituck, where two dogs had apparently been struck by an unknown vehicle, which then fled, according to a police report. Police canvassed the area for security cameras and witnesses.
Around 2:30 p.m., police were advised that there may be “undomiciled subjects” residing at a home on Front St. in Greenport. Police observed personal belongings in bags and garbage near the rear of the location. Extra patrols in the area were ordered.
Nov. 11 – Around 2:15 p.m., two members of a rod and gun club in Orient visited Southold police headquarters to report that a former club member had continued to hunt on properties leased by the club despite no longer having permission to do so, according to a report. The club leases two properties on Main Road and a third on Narrow River Road for hunting and shooting events, all of which are restricted to club members, the men told police. At their request, an officer prepared notices of trespass for all three properties and attempted to contact the 64-year-old former member, a Southold resident, but was unable to reach him.
Around 3:30 p.m., a Greenport West woman reported an ongoing dispute with a neighbor who she said repeatedly entered her property on Island View Lane, where her 92-year-old mother resides, without permission, according to a report. The woman told police that footage from her Ring surveillance camera appeared to show the neighbor using some type of pole or stick to knock down the camera. While the woman declined to press charges, police served the 68-year-old neighbor with a notice of trespass and warned him that he would be arrested if caught on the property again. The man acknowledged the warning and told police he would be away from his home for the winter anyway.
Nov. 12 – Around 3:45 p.m., a dispute over the whereabouts of a package at the Fishers Island Post Office prompted a police response after a postal employee reported that a frustrated customer was refusing to leave, according to a report. The 22-year-old New Jersey man had been at the post office since about 2 p.m. and said he had received a notification from UPS confirming that his package had been delivered. The postal employee insisted that if there was no yellow slip in his post office box, the package had not arrived and refused to check the back of the post office — even after a responding officer asked her to do so. Complicating matters, the man was scheduled to leave the island on the 8:15 a.m. ferry the following morning and would not return until late March. The employee told police that even if the package had arrived, it would not be processed in time for his departure. The man ultimately decided to have his boss retrieve the package and mail it to his home in New Jersey.
Around 8:45 p.m., a 21-year-old Calverton man was pulled over on Middle Road in Mattituck after a patrol officer spotted a vehicle with a suspended registration traveling westbound, according to a report. Police determined that the vehicle’s registration had been suspended for lack of insurance and that its inspection had expired more than a year earlier. The driver was issued traffic tickets, the vehicle was towed and its license plates were seized. A friend arrived to give the man a ride.
Nov. 13 – Around 2:35 p.m., police received a report of a vehicle traveling eastbound on Route 48 in Mattituck at a high rate of speed and passing other motorists. A responding officer located the vehicle near Ackerly Pond Lane and watched as the driver crossed a double yellow line to pass a gray pickup truck and continued traveling at more than 80 mph in a 45-mph zone, according to a report. The officer pulled over the driver, a 46-year-old Remsenburg-Speonk man, who explained that he was running late for a ferry. He was issued two traffic tickets.
Nov. 15 – Around 3:50 p.m., a 50-year-old Cutchogue woman visited police headquarters to report that mail was going missing from her Middle Road home, where she and her estranged husband continue to live together despite being in the midst of a divorce, according to a report. The woman said she suspected her husband had taken a bag containing a year’s worth of mail and stashed it in a shed on the property that he had locked her out of. She said mail had also gone missing directly from the couple’s mailbox. An officer responded to the residence but was unable to make contact with the husband. Police advised the woman to report the missing mail to the U.S. Postal Service.
All individuals named in police reports are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law. Charges may be reduced, dismissed or result in an acquittal.


