New York’s new medical aid-in-dying law is giving terminally ill residents the option to decide when and how to end their lives, a deeply personal choice that is beginning to generate inquiries at health care facilities across Long Island.

Gov. Kathy Hochul signed the historic legislation in February, and the law took effect Aug. 5. The North Fork Sun reached out to several health care facilities and attorneys on the East End to learn whether North Fork residents are considering the option.

According to the New York State Department of Health, the Medical Aid in Dying (MAID) law, Article 28-F of the Public Health Law, allows terminally ill adults to obtain a prescription for medication they can choose to self-administer to end their lives.

The concept has been debated in New York since the 1980s, when advocacy groups began lobbying lawmakers to change the law.

In a news release, the state Department of Health said the law expands end-of-life options for terminally ill New Yorkers and affirms their right to make voluntary, informed decisions about medical aid in dying.

“Decisions about end-of-life care are deeply personal and best reached on an individual basis in consultation with a person’s doctor, family and loved ones,” state Health Commissioner Dr. James McDonald said. “The Department has worked diligently and thoughtfully to establish guidance and to propose regulations designed to provide dignity and comfort to those who choose to use Medical Aid in Dying, while providing the necessary protections to ensure the law is not misused or inappropriately applied.”

At Peconic Bay Medical Center in Riverhead, Dr. Tara Liberman, senior vice president of Hospice Care Network at Northwell Health, said Northwell is receiving inquiries about MAID across its system of 10 facilities on Long Island.

Liberman declined to provide exact numbers or the geographic locations of those inquiries but said patients are being directed to Northwell’s medical aid-in-dying coordinator, a social worker.

“When a patient has a terminal illness and that person has only 6 months to live, we encourage them to enroll in hospice so they have the support. MAID is a self-directed program. The patient has to have the capacity to make that decision and they can utilize the law to end their suffering.”

She added that about 60% of patients who pursue the option actually take the medication.

“It’s about being in control and having the ability to have that control. When you’re dying you lose that control. You have to be awake, alert, and self-administer. Having hospice allows them to have support until the end of life.”

Under New York law, an attending physician and a consulting physician must agree that the patient has the capacity to make the decision and is not being coerced. A mental health professional must also assess the patient’s decision-making capacity.

“The majority of people with terminal illnesses who are enrolling have metastatic cancer, ALS, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) or those not accepting any further treatment. A patient with dementia cannot enroll because of the capacity issue,” Liberman said.

The law includes safeguards intended to prevent outside influences, including pressure from family members who might benefit financially from a patient’s death, from affecting the decision.

Liberman said family involvement is encouraged but not required.

“To have that support is important. My hope is that people are talking about end-of-life care and that families have become more open about the conversation.”

New York is now one of 13 states, along with Washington, D.C., to legalize medical aid in dying. Delaware and Illinois are among the most recent states to approve the option. Oregon became the first state to legalize the practice in 1997.

To qualify under New York’s law, a patient must have a terminal illness with a life expectancy of six months or less.

Liberman described the medication used in New York as a powder containing a combination of drugs that is mixed with liquid for the patient to drink. She declined to identify the ingredients.

Physicians are not required to participate in the process, although they must refer patients seeking the option to a participating doctor. Health care facilities may also opt out.

Northwell has established a medical aid-in-dying website that Liberman described as a resource for patients seeking information.

“It’s important to understand patients have a lot of support. People are not doing this by themselves. Every treatment decision is individualized.”

Patients pursuing medical aid in dying must document their wishes in writing and on video. For those unable to speak, alternative methods of communication, including sign language or speech-generating devices, may be used.

Tricia Marcin, a trusts and wills attorney from Cutchogue and a partner at Rivkin Radler LLC, said she has not yet received inquiries from North Fork residents seeking legal assistance with medical aid in dying.

“I don’t think people are aware of it yet. You also have to be terminally ill so that cuts down the pool of people who are eligible and with the likelihood that you will die in six months. Theoretically you could live longer than six months.”

Marcin said moral and religious beliefs may influence whether someone chooses medical aid in dying, but she believes having the option could make the process easier for loved ones.

“I think it’s good for people to know it’s there if they want it. Each case is individual with different situations and it’s really personal,” Marcin said.

Mark Antonucci, a partner in Rivkin Radler’s Albany office who represents health care facilities that choose to participate in MAID, said much of his work involves helping providers understand their legal obligations.

“We help them understand what the risks are and how to properly document everything. The concept of the law is straightforward regarding policies and procedures. Providers want to make sure they’re doing it properly.”

Antonucci said it is too early to determine how many hospitals and hospice centers across New York are participating.

“It’s too soon in New York to have data. The NYS DOH does want reporting done and there tends to be a lot of overlap with these options between hospice and hospitals. It’s going to take some time to see how it plays out and how widespread the use is.”

He added that for some terminally ill patients, it can be difficult to predict when death will occur or when they might lose the ability to make decisions independently.

At the Kanas Center for Hospice Care in Westhampton, President and CEO Mary C. Crosby said patients and their families are also beginning to ask about the new law.

“People and their families are wanting information and have questions about everything: who provides it, how you take it and how it all works.”

Crosby said the questions are expected, given how recently the law took effect.

“We respect everyone’s autonomy and the right to choose.”

Although Kanas does not provide the medication, Crosby said the center will continue caring for patients who choose medical aid in dying and will support their families.

“If they’re on hospice and decide they want MAID, we will support them and their families after the patient dies. It’s a complicated issue with complicated grief for family members who don’t necessarily agree with the patient’s choice.”

Crosby said experiences in other states suggest that some hospice patients who pursue medical aid in dying ultimately decide not to take the medication, in part because hospice care can effectively manage their pain.

“Hospice services are vastly underutilized. New Yorkers use it less than any other state in the country,” Crosby said. “We want people to know we prevent suffering and provide a peaceful death with dignity.”

She believes the discussion also reflects a broader cultural discomfort with death.

“There’s something about our culture that we’re open to the idea of ending our lives but still not being able to accept death when we enroll in hospice.”

Peconic Landing, the retirement community in Greenport, provided a statement emphasizing its commitment to compassionate care and compliance with state law.

“At Peconic Landing, we are committed to providing compassionate care and support to our members and their families. We remain dedicated to treating every individual with dignity, respect, and compassion while adhering to all applicable New York State laws and regulations,” said Eugene Allen, administrator of health services.

Calls and emails from the North Fork Sun seeking comment on the new law were not returned by Stony Brook University Hospital, New York Blood and Cancer Center in Riverhead, San Simeon by the Sound Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation in Greenport and Acadia Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation in Riverhead.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *