A $3.4 million sale in Southold led this week’s North Fork and Shelter Island real estate transfers, followed by a $2.41 million transaction on Shelter Island and a $2.03 million sale in Riverhead. Elsewhere, a commercial property on Pulaski Street in Riverhead sold for $7.5 million, while homes in East Marion, Cutchogue and Mattituck changed hands for more than $1 million. Below are this week’s North Fork and Shelter Island real estate transfers by location.
AQUEBOGUE
508 Main Road, a commercial property, sold for $1,530,000 from 508 Main Rd LLC to AMP-Marratime 508 Main LLC.
160 Church Lane sold for $750,000 from Aaron and Susan Kaufman to 158-160 Church Lane LLC.
BAITING HOLLOW
72 Jean Court sold for $999,000 from Christopher and Melissa Merkle to Vito and Karen D’Erasmo.
22 Donna Drive sold for $670,000 from the Estate of Harry Goldbach to Brayan Suarez and Paula Roa.
30 Center Drive sold for $595,000 from the Estate of Ruth Harris to Tyler and Alicia Crohan.
194 Oak Drive sold for $200,000 from Isabelle Miller to Marnie Gutsell Trust.
CALVERTON
2288 River Road sold for $539,990 from EP Hess LLC to Charles Jakubauskas and Danielle Bonner.
CUTCHOGUE
145 Baldwin Place sold for $1,625,000 from Linda Kerensky to Thomas and Deanie Graziano.
3985 Stillwater Avenue sold for $1,250,000 from Neal DeWaal to 3985 Stillwater Ave LLC.
735 Deerfoot Path sold for $1,099,000 from Timothy and Susan Ryan to Joseph and Emma Hinton.
EAST MARION
2045 Willow Drive sold for $1,825,000 from Modern Age Home Builders LLC to Sean and Jessica Pearse.
3190 The Long Way sold for $1,295,000 from Tara Berman to Fotios and Linda Koumpouras.
GREENPORT
609 First Street sold for $1,050,000 from Robin Mortillo to Ridgeback Homes LLC.
JAMESPORT
No real estate transfers were announced for Jamesport this week.
LAUREL
475 Wells Road sold for $875,000 from Dawn Duerwald to 475 Wells Road LLC.
MATTITUCK
530 Woodcliff Drive sold for $1,160,000 from Mark and Antonia Canellos to Matthew Metalios and Claire Allshouse.
910 New Suffolk Avenue sold for $1,050,000 from Anita Martingetti to Patricia McCauley and Phil Pulaski.
870 Horton Avenue sold for $699,000 from Benjamin and Victoria Hawkins to Roy and Amy Schelin.
NEW SUFFOLK
No real estate transfers were announced for New Suffolk this week.
ORIENT
A partial interest in 175 Uhl Lane sold for $770,000 from Andrea Thorstensen and Carolyn Cricenti to Carolyn and Giovanni Cricenti.
PECONIC
No real estate transfers were announced for Peconic this week.
RIVERHEAD
817 Pulaski Street, a commercial property, sold for $7,500,000 from 817 Pulaski Realty Co LLC to Prime Storage Riverhead LLC.
5 Sea Crest Drive sold for $2,025,000 from Villas at Roanoke LLC to Steven and Debra Bricker.
86 Louise Court sold for $999,000 from Judy Pinzone to Valerya Poltorak.
435 Middle Road sold for $600,000 from Amanda DeLong and Matthew Williams to Nadine Nunez.
2204 Cedar Path, a condominium, sold for $570,000 from Jean Donnelly to Carlo DeVivo.
1049 Woodcrest Avenue sold for $340,000 from Stephen Liotta to Leon Real Estate Investor LLC.
SHELTER ISLAND
7 Lake Drive sold for $2,412,500 from Anthony Consi Trust to Lake Drive Shelter Island Holdings LLC.
A partial interest in 10 Chequit Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, sold for $1,000,000 from Anthony and Anna Flower to Anna Flower.
SOUTHOLD
465 Ripple Water Lane sold for $3,400,000 from North Fork Building Company LLC to Sean and Laurie O’Neal.
350 Brigantine Drive sold for $750,750 from Deutsche Bank to Timothy and Noreen Gillin.
WADING RIVER
25 Maidstone Lane sold for $1,200,000 from Brandon and Ariana Jusas to Daniela Gomez and Jose Sanchez.
1835 Wading River Manor Road, an intra-family transfer of vacant land, sold for $360,000 from Bernard May to Thomas May.
Source: Suffolk Vision Inc., week ending Oct. 9, 2026.
