North Fork & Shelter Island real estate transfers
North Fork & Shelter Island real estate transfers

A Shelter Island Heights property topped this week’s North Fork and Shelter Island real estate transfers, selling for $5.85 million. Southold recorded sales of $2.725 million and $1.749 million, while a Mattituck property changed hands for $2.7 million and an Orient property sold for $2.14 million.

Baiting Hollow (11933)

  • 24 Kimberly Court — Salvatore Mastrangelo purchased the property from Jack Straw Realty LLC for $820,000.
  • 3105 Fox Hill Drive (condo) — Christopher Musso purchased the property from Francis and Christine Foti for $649,900.
  • 1101 Fox Hill Drive (condo) — Paul Magno purchased the property from Francis Weber and Francis Weber Jr. for $639,000.

Calverton (11933)

  • 20 Red Oak Court (foreclosure sale) — U.S. Bank purchased the property for $1,370,358. Mark J. Goldsmith was the referee and Kristine Rutigliano was the defendant.
  • 169 Southfield Road (foreclosure sale) — U.S. Bank purchased the property for $1,011,047. Robert H. Frampton was the referee and James and Catherine Donnellan were the defendants.
  • 82 Donna Drive — Leon Invest LLC purchased the property from William Robinson for $660,450.

Greenport (11944)

  • 216 North Street — Jana Crandal purchased the property from Brian Sack for $999,000.

Jamesport (11947)

  • 1260 Main Road — Michael and Nichole Callaghan purchased the property from Kelvin Kubo for $690,000.

Mattituck (11952)

  • 4260 Ole Jule Lane — Lascelle Family Trust purchased the property from Richard Eddison and Stephanie Massini for $2.7 million.

Orient (11957)

  • 1970 Village Lane — Amnon and Kathleen Bar-Tur purchased the property from Edward and Stephanie Guard for $2.14 million.
  • 23530 Main Road — Thomas Foster IRA purchased the property from Vincent and Terese Pette for $830,000.

Riverhead (11901)

  • 98 Scenic Lake Drive (condo) — Maria Dattolo purchased the property from Terri Lesser for $725,000.
  • 34 Daly Court — Jeffrey Hauser and Alexandra Waski purchased the property from Eugene and Joann Altman for $700,000.
  • 2001 Willow Pond Drive (condo) — Danielle Paci purchased the property from Ronald and Concetta Jacklitsch for $465,000.
  • 914 Osborn Avenue — 914 Osborn LLC purchased the property from Lena Harris for $375,000.

Shelter Island (11964)

  • 16 Shelterlands Path — Maribel Bermeo purchased the property from Rose and Mauro DiBenedetto for $1.14 million.

Shelter Island Heights (11965)

  • 28 South Menantic Road — 13 Spring Garden Ave Shelter Island LLC purchased the property from Robin Green and Mitchell Burgess for $5.85 million.

Southold (11971)

  • 1815 Laurel Avenue — Joshua Mandelbaum and Karen Walzer purchased the property from Marratime Capital V LLC for $2.725 million.
  • 480 Ackerly Pond Lane — 1031 Pros Titleholder 1400 LLC purchased the property from Town Creek Real Estate Inc. for $1.749 million.
  • 425 Rene Drive — R & R National Consulting LLC purchased the property from Steven and Christine Garms for $1.2 million.
  • 4130 Hortons Lane — Thomas and Jill Giovan purchased the property from Annamae Johnson Trust for $900,000.
  • 2035 Town Harbor Lane (partial interest) — Brian Adler and Karen Bertrand purchased a partial interest in the property from John Adler for $300,000.
  • 2035 Town Harbor Lane (partial interest) — Brian Adler and Karen Bertrand purchased a partial interest in the property from Paul Adler for $233,000.

Wading River (11792)

  • 205 Great Rock Drive — Zachary Kelly purchased the property from William & Ruth Shannon Trust for $779,500.
  • 104 19th Street — John and Jessica Ryan purchased the property from Brent and Katherine Loffreto for $750,000.
  • 7 Francis Street — Christian DeMarco and Gabrielle Gangi purchased the property from Eleanor McMullan for $695,000.
  • 144 Beach Road (intra-family) — George Aul purchased the property from the Estate of Thomas Cowan for $484,500.

Source: Suffolk Vision Inc., week ending Oct. 2, 2026.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *