The residential sales record for Shelter Island has just been raised by more than $3 million.
The six-bedroom waterfront home overlooking Gardiners Bay at 4 Dawn Lane, designed by famed architect Norman Jaffe, sold for $15,995 million. The previous town-high purchase price was set in 2023, when the property at 2 Charlies Lane sold for $12.95 million. That sales price was nearly matched last year with the $12.85 million purchase of 1 Pandion Road.
For the second time in four years, the five-bedroom, 4,440-square-foot house at 2100 Park Avenue showed up as having one of Mattituck’s highest-ever purchase prices. Timothy and Charene Murray sold the home for $5.75 million, the third-most a residential property has ever sold for in Mattituck. That is the highest sale price for a property in Mattituck since the pair bought 1140 Park Avenue for $10 million in October, 2024. Coincidentally, the $4.5 million the pair paid for 2100 Park Avenue in 2022 was the third-highest purchase price ever of a Mattituck residential property at the time.
Below are this week’s real estate transfers listed by location:
AQUEBOGUE
No real estate transfers were announced for Aquebogue this week.
CUTCHOGUE
No real estate transfers were announced for Cutchogue this week.
EAST MARION
No real estate transfers were announced for East Marion this week.
GREENPORT
Aron & Anne-Marie Jonas purchased the three-bedroom contemporary house on the Long Island Sound at 58425 Route 48, just west of the Sound View, from Ermenak & Bianka Kurusyan for $1.24 million.
Justin Farenga bought the three-bedroom ranch house at 55 Snug Harbor Road, on the east side of Gulf Pond, from Danielle Collica for $930,000.
George Papadionisopoulos and Eleni Vlaseros sold the four-bedroom Cape Cod house at 3060 North Road, near the northwest corner of Gulf Pond, to 3060NorthRd LLC for $635,700.
JAMESPORT
No real estate transfers were announced for Jamesport this week.
LAUREL
No real estate transfers were announced for Laurel this week.
MATTITUCK
Patrick & Michele Sweeny purchased the beachfront house overlooking Peconic Bay at 2100 Park Avenue, near Marratooka Point, from Timothy & Charene Murray for $5.75 million.
Brian & Nicole Ambers bought the three-bedroom house with in-ground pool at 355 Woodcliff Drive, by Mattituck Inlet, from Theresa Homan for $860,000.
Nikki & Daniel Dubinsky sold the two-bedroom cottage at 35 North Riley Avenue, by James Creek, to Salvatore & Danielle Rongo for $380,000.
ORIENT
Mark Orso and Hannah Newman purchased the three-bedroom ranch house at 2000 Greenway East, a short walk from Orient Beach State Park, from Bruce DiNuzzo for $875,000.
Aventura Orient LLC bought the 1,600-square-foot house at 1740 Village Lane, near Orient Yacht Club, from Donald Curtis for $870,000.
PECONIC
No real estate transfers were announced for Peconic this week.
RIVERHEAD
Moutafis Motors Ltd sold the commercial property at 840 Old Country Road, across the road from Riverhead Plaza, to Keshav 840 LLC for $6.4 million.
Christopher & Angela Zaia purchased the three-bedroom house at 420 Stonecrop Road, by the southeast corner of Long Island National Golf Club, from Jonathan Kratter for $870,000.
The Riley Family Trust bought the two-bedroom condo at 4 Haverton Court, near the south end of Woods at Cherry Creek, from Lillian Leka for $650,000.
Transformation Properties Inc sold the three-bedroom ranch house at 515 Sweezy Avenue, near Riverhead Middle School, to Marta Garcia and Americo Vasquez for $500,000.
Marjane Kaswan purchased the two-bedroom condo at 1503 Pebble Beach Path, near Woods at Cherry Creek, from the Simms Trust for $489,999.
Stay Capital LLC bought the three-bedroom house at 28 Nadel Drive, near Sandy Pond Links, from the Estate of Helen Cristiano for $280,000.
SHELTER ISLAND
Waheed Alli sold the 5,700-square-foot home at 4 Dawn Lane, near Hay Beach Point, to Reed & Delphine Krakoff for $15.995 million.
Eric Hecker purchased a partial interest in the house at 4 Tuthill Drive from Eric Hecker and Zoe Allen for $1.95 million.
Sarah Ross and Derrick Smith bought the two-bedroom house at 17 Ram island Road, near Whale’s Tale, from Frank & Mary Vincenti for $995,000.
SOUTHOLD
No real estate transfers were announced for Peconic this week.